academic debate departement stores in Indonesia should be minimized

MOTION	PRO		CONT
1.1 That departement stores in Indonesia should be minimized	1. Departement stores in Indonesia should be minimized because departement store building makes exclusion of one by one traditional markets, which in turn deadly activities of traditional indigenous traders. The number of traditional vendors increasingly reduced due to compete with modern market which gives more comfort. According to a survey conducted in the city of Bandung, the number of traditional traders who are still actively trader activity is around 9800, well below the 2007 estimate was about 13,000 active merchants, inversely proportional to the growth of the mall. During the year 2009 based on the survey, the number of malls in the city of Bandung growth around 31.4%. The number of mall uncontrollable causes a decrease in the number of traditional markets. 2. Development of many departement stores make a narrow land. A mall requires a lot of land for a single mall parking space is required, as much as mall building there are so little a land . It can cause ttraffic jam or noise polution because for build a mall they need to cut down some trees . According tantowi yahya as a member of DPR he said there is mall there is traffic jam because mall build in places crowded with traffic . Mall also suck a lot of electricity and water underground. More than 12 hours of mall operation, considered to have spent electrical energy by a large amount. Therefore, during the operation of the mall, during which the air conditioner (AC) electrical energy and other functionalized . 3. In social life a large mall would also generate a high gap between the rich and the poor. So that the poor will not be getting comfortable. Besides other effects mall development is citizens will be increasingly difficult to find an open space, such as watersheds or parks which in turn will lead to flooding. The social impact of mall development is citizens will be citizens of a consumerist stupor and spend time dimall, if the resident has the financial ability for shopping at the mall may not be a problem, but if the people do not have enough money, then what will happen is a crime that will be higher. Conclusion : In brief , departement stores in Indonesia sould be minimized because too many departement stores in Indonesia can gives bad effects in our daily life including in our social life . It can cause exclusion of one by one traditional markets , Development of many departement stores make a narrow land , and In social life a large mall would also generate a high gap between the rich and the poor .		1.Departement stores decrease unemployement . Every establishment mall means new employment. Every economic growth by 1% only absorb as much labor 250000-300000 workers. It able to cover the unemployment rate as much as 10 million more people in Indonesia. A mall has many kind of stores that need some employer , an store in a mall may need more than 2 or 3 employers or sometimes in a restaurant there are 7 or 8 employers . So in a mall there are need many employers to work there and it helps government to give job for unemployement . 2. Mall provides increased revenues in taxes, because of the economic activity there. Economic activity that occurred not too serious, because the factors driving urban transactions coming to the mall is certainly dominated by the upper middle class. Indeed they could have spent more than 100rb rupiah for each coming into the shopping center (accumulation of parking, shopping, eating and drinking, or other activities such as watching movies). So government can’t be minimized departement stores because it gives benefit in taxes for Indonesia . 3.Mall is appropriate with Indonesian comsumptive behaviour . Mall is a place provides facilities to accommodate all the needs of the community and the city at large . so that the mall becomes mandatory building which had almost the entire city center in Indonesia . And also our country is a tropical country so the mall is suitable for built in Indonesia as a place of entertainment and society for citizens . Conclusion : So , departement stores in Indonesia should not be minimized because there are many advantages from departement stores for economic in Indonesia . It can decrease unemployement in Indonesia , increased reveneus in taxes and Mall is appropriate with  Indonesian comsumptive behaviour .